Planting Seeds: Reflections on Gender, Language, and a Civilized Conversation
Introduction “What one remarkably civilized online discussion revealed about gender dysphoria, language, and the slow growth of understanding.” I follow an intersex woman on Facebook named Jackie Green. She regularly posts short educational videos about sex, gender, and biology, usually in a calm and accessible way. In one recent video, she responded to a charge often aimed at both intersex and transgender people, that they are “mentally ill.” In less than two minutes, Jackie explained something that still seems to get lost in many public arguments. Being transgender is not classified as a mental illness. What medicine recognizes is gender dysphoria, the distress that can arise when a person’s body and gender identity are experienced as being at odds. The purpose of care is not to erase identity, but to alleviate distress. Her explanation brought to mind a public exchange I had nearly fifteen years ago with Michael Brown, when I tried to make a similar point in a very different cli...