Skip to main content

Someone Asked If I Have Had a God Moment.

I've had many, but the question made me think specifically of Jacob wrestling God, how he walked with a limp thereafter, and how his name became Israel. You could say I too wrestled with God and in the end I too walk differently and have a new name! 

My struggle with God was during the process I went through in reconciling my faith with being transgender. But I still wonder why the solution to my deeply private struggle require I make such public and outward changes?

I transitioned in 2008 at the age of 58, nine years after I was diagnosed with having acute gender dysphoria. The recommended course of action would include living full time as a woman for at least one year, hormone therapy, legal name change, and undergoing a final psychological evaluation before surgery would be authorized.

The prospect was daunting, not just for its enormous financial cost, but also all the implications and ramifications on my wife and three adult sons. Nothing new here; this is the common experience for us who transition late in life, who are married and have children. Each family deals with the news differently and in many cases, the adjustment is painful and not without negative consequences.

I knew all this and was prepared for the worst. But this was not what held me back and gave me pause for concern. What did God have to say about this? Who’s opinion was I going to listen to, my doctors’ or God’s?

The way I had tried to deal with my dysphoria, from the age of twenty—when I place my faith in Jesus—until the fateful day I was given the diagnosis, was by spiritualizing it. I fully expected that one day I would be normal if I exercised my faith, prayed, memorized scripture and worked hard at “retraining my mind.” Unfortunately, the thoughts and feelings of inadequacy as a man were persistent. It seemed like such a simple prayer for God to answer so that this internal private struggle would simply vanish and I could be normal.

All these spiritual disciplines paid off dividends and if you were to look and me and my life, my family and how I was regarded by friends and family, you would have never guessed I was as torn up on the inside as I was. Don’t get me wrong, I loved being a husband and a dad; and I loved my life. The problem was that I never felt at peace in my own skin. This produced mountains of guilt and I felt totally defeated spiritually.

The word “transgender” was not available to me when I came out to my wife in 1980, about six years into our marriage. Maybe it would have made it a lot easier to explain how I felt and what I “feared” I was. Instead, all I could muster up was that I felt inadequate as a man; that I had feminine feelings and how embarrassed I was for being this way. I told her I sometimes wanted to be a woman and that I often found myself imagining what I would look like as a female. I went on to say that I wanted all these thoughts to go away and wondered if the reason God had chosen not to “heal” me was because I had ket this a secret from her.

I believed that when I married my wife, the two of us had be come one flesh in the eyes of God. I concluded, therefore, that by not being honest with her from the start, I must have sabotaged this process somehow. How could I possibly expect God to hear my prayers? She needed to know the truth.

That was my logic. Our marriage went through and adjustment period, but gradually my wife allowed herself to stand with me in this struggle and we fought the war together. I became very harsh with myself as I vainly tried to control my thoughts. Nothing worked; and as time went by, I lost hope. On top of that, I could not bring myself to tell my wife just how I was unraveling from the inside despite her love and best efforts to help me cope.

Unfortunately, our marriage ended the year after my surgery, I will always be grateful for how my wife gave me so much love and support, even before those challenging years of transition. In the end, she could not accept the loss of her husband. Sometimes the death of a spouse is easier to accept than having them change sex, I am told.

In my fundamentalist way of thinking, I needed to reduce things to black and white, cause and effect, dos and don’ts, to categorizing knowledge and wisdom into the world’s or to heaven’s; the world's is bad and heaven's is good. My attempts to figure out why I was this way became a minefield of conflicting thoughts. I felt guilty for looking at “secular” (bad) information and worried I would somehow jinx everything if I accepted these explanations. Unfortunately, I could find little that offered an explanation that made sense to me in “Christian” (good) literature.

Even getting myself referred to the gender clinic for a psychological evaluation became a struggle of conscience; it felt as if I was walking into enemy territory. But I needed to know once and for all if I could be fixed. The diagnosis was not a big surprise, I had suspected as much. But part of me was hopeful that doctors could somehow make it less overwhelming for me to live each day without the nagging self-loathing.

My God moment by moment:

The turning point in reconciling my very conservative beliefs to what the doctors were telling me was not one single “aha!” moment. It took several months in 2006 when I began to look more closely at what it was Jesus said about eunuchs. Ironically, the one verse I had used for years was part of this discussion between Jesus, the Pharisees and his disciples; but I had taken it out of context.

I won’t go into all the arguments I pondered at the time, but at the end of this grueling process, I finally felt I had permission to proceed and that God did not condemn me. I now had other questions to ponder, such as: why doesn’t God answer all our prayers and why did he choose not to “heal” me? But as I considered how universal these questions were and how I was not the only person who had pleaded with God for years to change something that seemed to be broken, I then began to see how perhaps I had missed his answers to my prayers all along.

Yes, I had a very specific request, I wanted to be normal. What I meant by that was that I did not want to be struggling with my gender identity; I wanted to be at home in my own body. This meant that I would one day be content to be a male, plain and simple.

Then, I considered how I lived in a time and place where my condition, if you want to call it that, was understood by the medical profession and that there were countless clinicians and specialists who were invested in making the lives of transgender people more livable. Was this not to be recognized as a gift from God and answer to prayer? It is no different from recognizing that each year there are medical advances that help those suffering from life-long ailments and conditions that had previously been life sentences.

Any one of the hallmark discoveries which have made it possible for people to live longer, happier lives, such as the discovery of insulin—it dawned on me how we consider these advances as answers to prayers, as gifts from God. Why, then, could I not accept the medical and surgical options the doctors recommended for me were his way of answering my prayers? There it was, the crux of the matter, God did answer my prayers, but not as I expected. One question that remains unanswered, however, is why the solution to my deeply private struggle required such public and outward changes.

Transition was no cakewalk. It was a frightening time of adjustments and navigating unchartered waters. No amount of reading other people’s stories can prepare you for some of the things one has to go through. The first time you present yourself to an old friend or acquaintance, the nerves are enough to kill a million tapeworms. Gradually, I began to discover that any of my fears were unfounded, I was not rejected, ostracized, or abandoned. I was fortunate.

After my transition, I have had the privilege of meeting and corresponding with countless other trans men and women. Sadly, for far too many, rejection has been their bitter experience. More disturbing is the fact that so many of those doing the rejecting and judging are Christian families and friends. It is no longer a wonder to me why so many trans persons want nothing to do with church, or with God.

That is not to say transgender persons are not spiritual; far from it. My experience within my faith community may not be the norm, I admit, but if we are to ask what true religion is, we would then need to say that loving justice, embracing mercy and walking humbly with God is it. Simply put, to love others as we want to be loved. Whether my new friends claim to be Christian or not, I sometimes see more of this type of love in action among transgender persons than among some of our detractors who do claim to be Christian.

Since I published my story in 2011, “Transparently: behind the Scenes of a Good Life,” in which I share my journey from childhood through to just after my gender reassignment surgery in March of 2010, I have received many letters. They tell me my book is the first one they have read that talks about faith and being transgender. Why is this significant, you may ask? The reality is that for many, being a transgender Christian is an oxymoron, a contradiction. I am touched by these letters, some of which have come from transgender Christians who have yet to come out and are terrified that they will loose everything if and when they do, family, church, jobs, etc. This saddens me deeply.

The young transgender girl, Sadie Croft (11), who wrote President Obama after his Inaugural Address, hit the nail on the head. Disappointed the President had not mentioned transgender persons when he talked about equality, she said:
“It would be a better world if everyone knew that transgender people have the same hopes and dreams as everyone else.”

When this becomes a reality, what a God moment that will be! 

Popular posts from this blog

Behind the scenes of "Ask a transgender Christian"

A young woman I greatly admire is Rachel Held Evans. She is an amazing author, blogger, speaker, wife, mother and a seriously articulate Evangelical Christian who is not afraid to enter into conversations that would make many others run and hide in their little dogma houses.

Earlier in September of 2012, Rachel contacted me to see if I would be willing to be interviewed as part of her popular blog series titled "AKS A…" Would I be willing to be the target for "Ask a Transgender Christian?"My new friend Justin Lee, executive director of the Gay Christian Network (GCN) and author of the soon to be released book"Torn: Rescuing the Gospel from the Gays-vs.-Christians Debate" suggested me as the person to ask. (In the same way, Justin is the person Rachel chose for the "Ask a Gay Christian" interview.

Having followed Rachel for several months, my initial reaction to her email was one of disbelief and trepidation, given the level of intellectual and t…

Cats and dogs seem to matter more to the ruling BC Liberals than trans persons.

The Apparent Hypocrisy of British Columbia’s Elected Liberal Government
The same week that Transgender advocates and allies stood in front of the BC Legislature in support of the introduction of a private member’s bill aimed at protecting the rights of transgender people, the BC Liberal Government announced an order-in-council that adopts the Canadian Veterinary Medical Association’s Codes of Practice for both kennel and cat breeding.

Indeed, this is very good news for dogs and cats in British Columbia.
Yet, this same Government has sat intentionally on it’s laurels, refusing to pass an exact version of the “trans rights bill” on three previous occasions. This is the fourth time the Honourable Spencer Chandra Herbert, MLA for Vancouver-West End, introduces this bill. The bill would amend the BC Human Rights Code (BCHRC) to include “gender identity and gender expression.”
Having “gender identity and gender expression” included in the BCHRC will afford increased protection, safety, and …

Witnessing a Birth of Sorts

When the moment to start life anew comes, it usually happens in the quietness of one's spirit. Yesterday, February 21, 2012 will mark the moment my friend Tori took that step in the most unassuming way.

In 1999, about the time I was being assessed and diagnosed at the Vancouver Hospital's Gender Clinic, I made a couple of calls to a support group in the area. Their brochure listed a phone number and stated calls could be made on Thursday nights if you needed to speak to someone, otherwise you could leave a message and someone would get back to you. The woman who answered was friendly and explained the purpose of the group an how one would go about attending their meetings and other events. Membership was reserved for those who had been vetted and approved by the membership committee. Confidentiality and security of personal information was very high on the group's priority list.

Given the group's stated purposed was to provide a safe place for heterosexual men to cross…